Milton Coste

Licensed Real Estate Associate Broker

(917) 416-7433

NYC Neighborhood Comparison

Bensonhurst vs Mill Basin

Side-by-side market data, transit, and neighborhood profiles to help you decide.

Brooklyn|Brooklyn

Bensonhurst

Brooklyn

Mill Basin

Brooklyn

How They Compare

For buyers focused on affordability, Mill Basin has the lower median sale price at $1.3M vs $1.3M in Bensonhurst.

Median Sale Price
$1.3M
$1.3M
Median Rent
$2K
$2K
Active Listings
71
25
Avg Days on Market
36 days
0 days
YoY Price Change
+11.3%
+76.4%
Monthly Sales Volume
12
3

Detailed Comparison

MetricBensonhurstMill Basin
Median Sale Price$1,290,000$1,252,500
Median Condo Price$556,473.5N/A
Median Co-op PriceN/AN/A
Median Rent$2,400$2,400
Active Listings7125
Rental Inventory353
Days on Market360
Price Cut Share12.7%4.0%
Monthly Sales Volume123
YoY Price Change+11.3%+76.4%
YoY Rent Change+2.1%0.0%
YoY Inventory Change-4.1%+8.7%
Subway LinesN/AN/A

Year-Over-Year Price Movement

Prices in Bensonhurst moved +11.3% over the past year, compared to +76.4% in Mill Basin. The +76.4% gain in Mill Basin reflects stronger buyer demand relative to available inventory in that market.

Neighborhood Profiles

Bensonhurst

Bensonhurst is a densely built Brooklyn neighborhood of six-story prewar apartment buildings, attached brick row houses, and two-family homes along wide commercial avenues. The D train runs along an elevated section of 86th Street, and the N train serves the Bath Beach border to the west. Bensonhurst Park and the Gravesend Bay waterfront provide green space along the southern edge.

View Full Market Report

Mill Basin

Mill Basin is a waterfront neighborhood in southeastern Brooklyn defined by detached single-family brick houses, many with private docks and direct access to Jamaica Bay. The housing stock ranges from mid-century brick bungalows to large custom-built homes on generous 50-by-100-foot lots. Marine Park offers 798 acres of trails and athletic fields nearby.

View Full Market Report

Transit Access

Bensonhurst

No subway data available

Mill Basin

No subway data available

Active Listings

Bensonhurst for sale

View all Bensonhurst listings

Mill Basin for sale

View all Mill Basin listings

Listing data is derived in whole or in part from the RLS at REBNY (Real Estate Board of New York) Internet Data Exchange (IDX) database. Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Milton Coste | Keller Williams NYC are marked with the RLS logo. The information provided is for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Data last updated: 1/1/1970.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Bensonhurst cheaper than Mill Basin?
Mill Basin is more affordable, with a median sale price of $1,252,500 vs $1,290,000 in Bensonhurst. Pricing can vary widely by building, floor, and unit condition, so review current listings for accurate comparisons.
Which has better transit, Bensonhurst or Mill Basin?
Transit data is not available for these neighborhoods. Check the MTA website for current service maps.
Which is better for families, Bensonhurst or Mill Basin?
This depends on what type of home fits your household. Bensonhurst and Mill Basin both offer a mix of apartment and multi-room units in co-ops, condos, and townhouses. Larger 3- and 4-bedroom units, including townhouses and multi-family properties, tend to be more available in lower-density areas. Reviewing active listings filtered by bedroom count is the most reliable way to see what each neighborhood currently offers for larger households. A licensed broker can pull current inventory by bedroom count across both areas for a direct comparison.
Should I buy in Bensonhurst or Mill Basin?
The right neighborhood depends on your price range, commute needs, and preferred property type. A comparative market analysis (CMA) of recent sales in both Bensonhurst and Mill Basin gives you the clearest picture of what your budget gets in each location. Request a free CMA from Milton Coste to get a side-by-side breakdown of current opportunities.

More Comparisons

Need Help Choosing?

With 25+ years of experience across all five boroughs, I can help you find the right neighborhood for your lifestyle and budget.

Call Milton WhatsApp