Schedule with Milton
Licensed Real Estate Associate Broker
Regarding Property
You're Confirmed!
Milton will reach out within 24 hours to finalize your appointment.
25+ years experience · 1,000+ transactions · 5-star reviews
NYC Neighborhood Comparison
Manhattan
Brooklyn
For buyers focused on affordability, Hamilton Heights has the lower median sale price at $445K vs $611K in Sheepshead Bay.
Investors analyzing rental yield will find Hamilton Heights offers a stronger rent-to-price ratio based on current market data.
Commuters have more transit options in Hamilton Heights, which is served by 5 subway lines compared to 0 in Sheepshead Bay.
| Metric | Hamilton Heights | Sheepshead Bay |
|---|---|---|
| Median Sale Price | $445,000 | $611,000 |
| Median Condo Price | $625,000 | $550,000 |
| Median Co-op Price | $325,000 | $204,000 |
| Median Rent | $3,250 | $2,958 |
| Active Listings | 103 | 362 |
| Rental Inventory | 207 | 110 |
| Days on Market | 25.5 | 66 |
| Price Cut Share | 11.7% | 14.1% |
| Monthly Sales Volume | 5 | 29 |
| YoY Price Change | +17.1% | -20.1% |
| YoY Rent Change | +4.8% | +13.8% |
| YoY Inventory Change | +5.1% | +5.8% |
| Subway Lines | 1 A B C D | N/A |
Prices in Hamilton Heights moved +17.1% over the past year, compared to -20.1% in Sheepshead Bay. Hamilton Heights is seeing price appreciation while Sheepshead Bay has softened, pointing to different supply-demand dynamics in each market.
Hamilton Heights is a historic and architecturally stunning section of Harlem, named after Alexander Hamilton. The neighborhood is famous for its grand row houses and the beautiful campus of City College. Residents enjoy proximity to Riverbank State Park and a growing number of cafes and restaurants. The real estate market features a mix of impeccably preserved historic townhouses, value-driven HDFC cooperatives, and modern boutique developments.
View Full Market ReportSheepshead Bay is a scenic waterfront neighborhood in Southern Brooklyn, famous for its fishing fleet, piers, and seafood restaurants. The area offers a unique maritime atmosphere with a relaxed, residential vibe. The real estate market features a mix of traditional multi-family brick houses, spacious pre-war cooperatives, and a growing number of modern luxury condominiums that offer stunning views of the bay and easy access to the beaches of Coney Island and Manhattan Beach.
View Full Market Report145 St (1 A B C D) — 0.2 mi
125 St (1) — 0.7 mi
No subway data available
Listing data is derived in whole or in part from the RLS at REBNY (Real Estate Board of New York) Internet Data Exchange (IDX) database. Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Milton Coste | Keller Williams NYC are marked with the RLS logo. The information provided is for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Data is refreshed every 15 minutes per REBNY IDX requirements.
From the 2008 financial crisis through the 2020 pandemic, the NYC metro Case-Shiller composite fell about 25% peak-to-trough between 2007 and 2012, then fully recovered by 2017 and gained another 15% through Q1 2020. Hamilton Heights and Sheepshead Bay both tracked this broader NYC arc, with annual closing volume contracting sharply in 2009 and again in Q2 2020 before normalizing.
Hamilton Heights tracked the more resilient Manhattan price path with a 10% to 15% peak-to-trough decline, while Sheepshead Bay moved closer to the broader NYC metro pattern of a 20% to 25% retracement before recovering through 2017.
Source: Per Case-Shiller Home Price Index, NYC metro subset, 2008-2020, cross-referenced with StreetEasy historical price data series.
| Metric (2026) | Hamilton Heights | Sheepshead Bay |
|---|---|---|
| Median Sale Price | $445,000 | $611,000 |
| Median Rent | $3,250/mo | $2,958/mo |
| Year-over-Year Price Change | +17.1% | -20.1% |
| Average Days on Market | 25.5 days | 66 days |
| Distance to Nearest Subway | 0.20 mi | N/A |
Table values reflect current 2026 market conditions. Historical 2008-2020 commentary is sourced from Case-Shiller NYC metro composite and StreetEasy historical series.
With 25+ years of experience across all five boroughs, I can help you find the right neighborhood for your lifestyle and budget.
Data updated:
