Coney Island
Market Report • Data Range: 2010-01 to 2025-11
Median Sale Price
$368K
-16.5% YoY
What this means:
Half of homes sell for more than this price, half sell for less. This is the "middle" price point in the neighborhood.
Median Rent
$3,220
-0.8% YoY
What this means:
The typical monthly rent in this area. Half of apartments rent for more, half for less. Budget accordingly!
Days on Market
75.5
-14.7% YoY
What this means:
Average time a home sits before selling. Lower = hot market (buyers compete). Higher = more negotiating power for buyers.
For Sale Inventory
34
-22.7% YoY
What this means:
Number of homes currently for sale. More inventory = more choices for buyers. Low inventory = sellers have advantage.
Median Condo Price
$499K
Condos explained:
You own the unit outright. Easier financing, fewer restrictions, but often higher HOA fees. Great for investors or those who want flexibility.
Median Co-op Price
$340K
Co-ops explained:
You buy shares in a corporation that owns the building. Often cheaper than condos, but stricter board approval, subletting rules, and down payment requirements (often 20-50%).
Rental Inventory
104
What this means:
Number of apartments available for rent right now. More options = more bargaining power for renters. Low inventory? Act fast and come prepared!
Price Cut Share
20.0%
What this means:
Percentage of listings that reduced their asking price. High % = sellers overpricing, room to negotiate. Low % = homes priced right, less wiggle room.
Sales Volume (mo)
9
What this means:
Number of homes sold last month. Shows how active the market is. High volume = competitive market. Low volume = fewer comparable sales for pricing.
Rent-to-Own Ratio
10x
Annual rent
Should you buy or rent?
This shows how many years of rent equals the purchase price. Under 15x = buying may be better. Over 20x = renting may make more sense. 15-20x = toss-up, depends on your situation.
Market Trends & Analytics
Median Sale Price
-16.5% YoYMedian Rent
-0.8% YoYFor-Sale Inventory
Days on Market
Sales Volume
Explore All Market Metrics
Select any metric from 43 StreetEasy data sets
Median Sales Price
--
Data Range
2023-12 to 2025-11
24 months of history
Sub-Type
All Properties
Median price of recently sold properties
Market Insights
Price Trend
Sale prices in Coney Island have decreased 16.5% over the past year, underperforming the NYC average.
Rental Market
Rental prices fell 0.8% YoY. At $3220/mo, Coney Island offers moderate rentals for Brooklyn.
Investment Outlook
With a price-to-rent ratio of 10x annual rent, Coney Island favors buyers/investors based on current metrics.
Active Listings in Coney Island
Loading listings...
No active listings in Coney Island at the moment.
Contact Milton for off-market opportunities or upcoming listings.
Coney Island Market Snapshot
View Full Market Report →Closed Deals in Coney Island
Milton's Track Record
0
Total Deals
Loading transactions...
Get Expert Guidance on Coney Island
With 25+ years of experience and 1,000+ properties listed, marketed, sold, and leased in NYC, I can help you navigate the Coney Island market. Whether buying, selling, or investing, let's discuss your goals.