Milton Coste

Licensed Real Estate Associate Broker

(917) 416-7433

Recently Sold in Sheepshead Bay

442 closed sales in Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn

Explore recent closing prices to understand current market values and comp data.

Recent Sales in Sheepshead Bay

Closed sales data is essential for understanding real market values in Sheepshead Bay. Unlike asking prices, closing prices reflect what buyers actually paid after negotiation. Use this data for comparable sales analysis when pricing a home or making an offer.

Thinking about selling? Get a free property valuation from Milton Coste, or view the Sheepshead Bay market report for current trends.

2140 OCEAN Avenue #5B Closed

$459,000

Condo
1 bd | 1 ba |839 sqft

2140 OCEAN Avenue #5B

Sheepshead Bay

Serhant RLS
2546 E 13TH Street #B13 Closed

$390,000

Co-op
2 bd | 1 ba |1,100 sqft

2546 E 13TH Street #B13

Sheepshead Bay

Douglas Elliman Real Estate RLS
2222 E 29th Street Closed

$800,000

Single Family Residence
2 bd | 2 ba |1,679 sqft

2222 E 29th Street

Sheepshead Bay

Compass RLS
2511 Ocean Avenue #304 Closed

$648,000

Condo
2 bd | 2 ba |1,165 sqft

2511 Ocean Avenue #304

Sheepshead Bay

Remax Edge RLS
1717 E 18th Street #3-C Closed

$525,000

Co-op
2 bd | 2 ba |1,250 sqft

1717 E 18th Street #3-C

Sheepshead Bay

Weichert Properties RLS
3311 SHORE Parkway #5G Closed

$285,000

Co-op
1 bd | 1 ba

3311 SHORE Parkway #5G

Sheepshead Bay

Douglas Elliman Real Estate RLS
2330 VOORHIES Avenue #LC Closed

$190,000

Co-op
0 bd | 1 ba

2330 VOORHIES Avenue #LC

Sheepshead Bay

Brown Harris Stevens Residential Sales LLC RLS
2511 OCEAN Avenue #301 Closed

$770,000

Condo
3 bd | 2 ba |1,250 sqft

2511 OCEAN Avenue #301

Sheepshead Bay

Corcoran Group RLS
2171 Bragg Street #5-G Closed

$215,000

Co-op
2 bd | 1 ba |870 sqft

2171 Bragg Street #5-G

Sheepshead Bay

Keller Williams Realty Empire RLS
1670 E 19TH Street #4C Closed

$476,000

Condo
1 bd | 1 ba |588 sqft

1670 E 19TH Street #4C

Sheepshead Bay

Serhant RLS
2040A E 12th Street Closed

$1,125,000

Single Family Residence
0 bd | 0 ba |3,167 sqft

2040A E 12th Street

Sheepshead Bay

The Agency RLS
1674 E 22ND Street #5A Closed

$450,000

Condo
2 bd | 2 ba |932 sqft

1674 E 22ND Street #5A

Sheepshead Bay

Daniel Gale of Brooklyn LLC RLS
2546 E 13TH Street #B9 Closed

$430,000

Co-op
2 bd | 1 ba |1,229 sqft

2546 E 13TH Street #B9

Sheepshead Bay

Douglas Elliman Real Estate RLS
1855 E 12TH Street #2N Closed

$205,000

Co-op
1 bd | 1 ba |550 sqft

1855 E 12TH Street #2N

Sheepshead Bay

Douglas Elliman Real Estate RLS
2375 OCEAN Avenue #1C Closed

$165,000

Co-op
0 bd | 1 ba |525 sqft

2375 OCEAN Avenue #1C

Sheepshead Bay

Daniel Gale of Brooklyn LLC RLS
2711 Ave X #5F Closed

$280,000

Co-op
2 bd | 1 ba |1,000 sqft

2711 Ave X #5F

Sheepshead Bay

Abacus Properties RLS
2601 E 24TH Street #1B Closed

$600,000

Condo
3 bd | 3 ba

2601 E 24TH Street #1B

Sheepshead Bay

Brooklyn Real Property Inc RLS
2826 BRAGG Street #NA Closed

$1,398,000

Multi Family
9 bd | 4 ba |3,564 sqft

2826 BRAGG Street #NA

Sheepshead Bay

Brooklyn Real Property Inc RLS
2263 E 18TH Street #NA Closed

$1,080,000

Single Family Residence
3 bd | 2 ba |1,989 sqft

2263 E 18TH Street #NA

Sheepshead Bay

Brooklyn Real Property Inc RLS
2259 E 18TH Street #NA Closed

$925,000

Single Family Residence
3 bd | 2 ba |1,399 sqft

2259 E 18TH Street #NA

Sheepshead Bay

Brooklyn Real Property Inc RLS
2451 E 22nd Street #0 Closed

$1,499,000

Single Family Residence
7 bd | 5 ba |2,596 sqft

2451 E 22nd Street #0

Sheepshead Bay

Remax Edge RLS
Closed

$999,999

Condo
1 bd | 1 ba

240 W END Avenue #7D

Sheepshead Bay

Brown Harris Stevens Residential Sales LLC RLS
3041 Ocean Avenue #PH-4 Closed

$1,249,888

Condo
3 bd | 2 ba |1,357 sqft

3041 Ocean Avenue #PH-4

Sheepshead Bay

Compass RLS
2216 E 24th Street Closed

$1,240,000

Single Family Residence
5 bd | 3 ba |2,425 sqft

2216 E 24th Street

Sheepshead Bay

Compass RLS
Previous Page 6 of 19 Next

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the average sale price in Sheepshead Bay?
Sale prices in Sheepshead Bay vary by property type and size. Visit the Sheepshead Bay market report for current median prices broken down by bedroom count.
How long does it take to sell in this neighborhood?
Days on market varies by season and pricing strategy. The Sheepshead Bay market report tracks average days on market so you can benchmark your listing.

Explore More

Sheepshead Bay Market ReportActive Listings in Sheepshead BaySell Your NYC PropertyNYC Buyer Guide
This information is not verified for authenticity or accuracy and is not guaranteed and may not reflect all real estate activity in the market. ©2026 The Real Estate Board of New York, Inc., All rights reserved.
Call Text Valuation