About Coney Island
Coney Island provides a tranquil setting for those seeking space and value within New York City. The area is known for its unpretentious atmosphere and a real estate market that features a blend of tranquil cooperatives and traditional multi-family residences.
Your Coney Island Expert
Milton Coste was born and raised in the Washington Heights/Inwood area and has been helping buyers and sellers in Upper Manhattan and across NYC for over 25 years. With 1,000+ closed transactions including dozens in Coney Island, Milton knows every building, every block, and what it takes to navigate NYC's unique co-op and condo market.
Frequently Asked Questions: Coney Island Real Estate
Who is the best real estate agent in Coney Island?
What are Coney Island apartment prices in 2026?
What is the process for buying a co-op in Coney Island?
What Clients Say
View All Reviews"Milton helped us buy our first home in Washington Heights. He knew the neighborhood inside and out, negotiated a great price, and guided us through every step of the closing process."
Maria R.
Buyer • Washington Heights
"Milton is excellent - my apartment transition went absolutely seamless, and quick! He is very responsive and was extremely informed about both my property and the area."
Tim W.
Seller • Washington Heights
Current Inventory Snapshot
Live from REBNY/RLS • Feb 17, 2026
There are currently 5 properties actively listed for sale, with 0 already under contract. The median asking price is $670K ($355/sqft). Properties are spending an average of N/A days on market, and 0.0% of listings have had price reductions.
Inventory & Activity
Active Listings
5
for sale
Pending Sales
0
under contract
New This Week
1
last 7 days
New This Month
2
last 30 days
Avg Days on Market
N/A
days avg
Price Cut Rate
0.0%
0 listings
Asking Prices
Median Asking Price
$670K
all types
Average Asking Price
$879K
all types
Median $/Sqft
$355
per sqft
Median Condo Price
N/A
0 condos
Median Co-op Price
$437K
2 co-ops
Property Mix
Building Types:
Recent Sales
Sold (30 Days)
0
last 30 days
Sold (90 Days)
2
last 90 days
Median Sale Price
$575K
closed sales
Avg Sale Price
$575K
closed sales
Sale-to-List Ratio
100.0%
of asking
Browse by Property Type
Buildings in Coney Island
448 Neptune Avenue #16K
Coney Island
3122 NEPTUNE Avenue
Coney Island
2932 W 5TH Street #2C
Coney Island
1411 NEPTUNE Avenue
Coney Island
3848 Atlantic Avenue
Coney Island
Explore Nearby Neighborhoods
Helpful Resources for Coney Island Buyers
Looking to Buy or Sell in Coney Island?
With 25+ years of experience and 1,000+ deals closed, Milton Coste is your trusted Coney Island expert. Get a free consultation today.